Page 11 - The Indian EYE 050826

EYE ON INDIA MAY 08, 2026 | The Indian Eye 11

Fractures in Consensus:

Is the Iran War Testing BRICS Unity?

Diverging positions on West Asia are exposing fault lines within BRICS, raising questions

about the bloc’s ability to act cohesively on global crises.

OUR BUREAU
New Delhi
he inability of BRICS members to issue a
joint statement following a key meeting on
TWest Asia has triggered fresh debate over
whether the ongoing regional conflict—shaped in
part by tensions involving Iran—is casting a shadow
over the grouping’s unity and global ambitions.
The BRICS Deputy Foreign Ministers and
Special Envoys meeting on the Middle East and
North Africa (MENA), held in New Delhi on
April 23–24, ended with only a Chair’s Summary
rather than a consensus document. According to
the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA), the failure
to agree on a joint statement stemmed from deep
divisions among member states over the evolving
conflict in West Asia.
“A joint statement was not possible because a
general consensus could not be reached among the
members… regarding the ongoing conflict in West
Asia,” MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said,
rejecting what he described as “speculative and in-
accurate reporting” around the issue.
The development is significant for a grouping Secretary (South), Dr. Neena Malhotra meets Russia’s Deputy Foreign Minister Borisenko Georgy, on the sidelines of the BRICS
that has positioned itself as a platform for coordi- MENA Consultations, in New Delhi (@MEAIndia X/ANI Photo)
nation among emerging economies on global polit-
ical and economic governance. BRICS—compris-
ing countries such as India, China, Russia, Brazil participants, including Palestine. The comparison Sergey Lavrov is scheduled to visit New Delhi in
and South Africa, alongside newer members in- underscores how BRICS, despite its ambitions, May for the Foreign Ministers’ meeting, which is
cluding Iran, the UAE and others—has expanded may struggle to align diverse geopolitical priorities. expected to focus on strengthening strategic part-
both in size and geopolitical scope. That expansion, India’s own position has also come under nerships and addressing pressing global issues.
however, is now testing its internal coherence. scrutiny. Jairam Ramesh alleged that New Delhi’s Russian officials have described the upcoming
At the heart of the divergence are conflict- insistence on “diluting the language on Israel and engagement as a “valuable platform for substan-
ing national interests and geopolitical alignments Palestine” contributed to the deadlock, claiming tive discussions on current international issues and
within the bloc. Congress leader Jairam Ramesh that such a stance was unacceptable to several prospects for strengthening global governance.”
pointed to “divergent positions” between Iran and other members, including Russia, China, Brazil Yet, the shadow of recent disagreements suggests
the United Arab Emirates as one of the reasons and South Africa. While the government has not that achieving substantive outcomes may require
for the lack of consensus, arguing that such dif- directly addressed this claim, it highlights the bal- navigating complex internal dynamics.
ferences were “only to be expected” in a grouping ancing act India faces as it navigates competing The Iran factor is central to this challenge. As
with varied regional stakes. partnerships in a volatile region. both a regional actor directly linked to West Asian
The West Asia crisis itself is multi-layered, en- The implications extend beyond diplomatic geopolitics and a relatively new member of BRICS,
compassing the Gaza conflict, tensions involving Isra- optics. BRICS has sought to position itself as a Iran brings with it strategic priorities that may not
el, ceasefire dynamics in Lebanon, and broader insta- voice of the “global majority,” advocating reforms always align with those of other members. Its po-
bility across countries like Syria, Yemen and Sudan. in global governance and offering alternative sitions on regional conflicts, particularly those in-
According to the MEA, discussions at the BRICS frameworks to Western-led institutions. However, volving Israel and the Gulf states, can complicate
meeting covered all these areas, including humani- the inability to agree on a joint statement in the consensus-building within the bloc.
tarian aid, the role of UNRWA, a zero-tolerance ap- face of a major geopolitical crisis raises questions For now, the events in New Delhi serve as a
proach to terrorism, and post-conflict reconstruction. about its effectiveness as a unified actor. reminder that as BRICS grows in ambition and
The absence of consensus is particularly strik- The timing adds another layer of complexity. membership, it must also grapple with the realities
ing when contrasted with other multilateral en- India, currently chairing BRICS under the theme of divergent interests. The shadow cast by the Iran-
gagements. Jaiswal cited the India-Arab League “Building for Resilience, Innovation, Cooperation linked conflict may not define the bloc, but it has
Foreign Ministers’ meeting earlier this year, where and Sustainability,” is preparing to host the 18th certainly exposed the challenges of speaking in one
a joint statement was successfully endorsed by all BRICS Summit later this year. Ahead of that, voice in an increasingly divided world.

www.TheIndianEYE.com